Learning from the Curriculum for Excellence

I've just jumped onto the train, having spent the day at Holyrood's "Learning from the Curriculum for Excellence" conference. Here are a few of the bits of information that stuck in my head.

Bill Maxwell, Education Scotland
  • We need people who are good at learning
  • The 4 capacities are just as relevant in the senior phase
  • The centre is not looking to impose one curriculum model for the senior phase (but authorities may be I guess!)
  • BTC skills document is the least read (but I heard someone later describing it as gobbledygook! ).
  • Pathways are good for high attainers, not so good for lowest attaining 20%
  • We need to challenge  unspoken assumptions. 
  • CFE is designed to be a flexible model for development that will work for decades
  • Senior Phase needs to be planned across an an authority, working with FE colleges, local employers and other partners
  • We need to do a better job of communicating CfE rationale to parents and pupils

Janet Brown, SQA

  • SQA are conscious that new qualifications must match expectations of CfE - must not be simply tests that leaners are trained to pass
  • Vocational and academic qualifications have equal status in terms of SCQF levels - this is unusual internationally, and a strength of our system
  • New structure is very clear for employers
  • New "Awards" can be delivered at S3 - RBV, Personal Development Award etc
  • High external verification in years 1 to 3, in November, February and May, with over 2000 staff nominated to support this.
  • QA "intelligence led", with a partnership approach
Tony McDaid, former HT Calderglen HS
  • Curriculum should be defined around vision, but developing a vision takes time!
  • strength based school, not a deficit model
  • improvement focused on pedagogy: AfL; Active Learning; ICT to support learning; joined up skills development across school; resilient learners
  • IDL with progression - S2 out of timetable for a month, doing projects
Dr Alasdair Allan MSP
  • "We are seeing a variety of approaches to Senior Phase, and rightly so"
Iain Ellis - chair of National Parents Forum Scotland
  • "Nationals in a Nutshell" and "Learning Journeys" on the website
  • secondary schools are not utilising the resource that parents represent
  • all pupils should learn a second language in primary
University Speakers
  • 9 universities have published papers on revised admissions policies
  • "Beyond the Senior Phase" paper on Universities Scotland website
  • 25% of Glasgow Uni places filled through programmes to support access from deprived areas
  • Edinburgh Uni is abandoning consideration of Nat 5 awards in admissions
  • Edinburgh only needs 3 Highers to be sat concurrently
  • Edinburgh is about to publish position on Lifeskills 5 maths
  • Glasgow Uni has three tier system based on Highers - "Guaranteed Unconditional Offer, "Immediate Rejection" and "Gathered Field" in the middle

Popular posts from this blog

Assessment Through The Looking Glass

The old 5-14 assessments used to give robust, consistent answers to specific questions. The questions were of the form "what percentage of P7 students have managed to score at least 15 marks in one of a specific set of nationally generated assessment instruments". We thought that the questions were of the form "what percentage of P7 students have passed level D mathematics", but of course that isn't what we were measuring. We were measuring performance in tests. The mistaking of test performance for evidence of "passing a level" was bad, but we were right in thinking that we compared like with like as we looked at performance data from across Scotland.

Now we have abandoned national tests, and have moved towards measuring "passing a level" based on a combination of a rich bundle of assessments and teacher professional judgement. But what does it actually mean to have passed level 3 in numeracy? CfE documentation talks about assessing breadth…
Read more

And what if we don't achieve our dreams?

"If A then B" is logically equivalent to "If (Not B) then (Not A)". For example "if a shape has three sides, then it is a triangle" is logically equivalent to "if a shape is not a triangle, then it does not have three sides". The second statement in quotes is called the contrapositive of the first statement in quotes. Logically speaking, they are identical statements. If one is true, the other must be, and vice versa. In this case, they are both true statements.
A commonly touted inspirational message we deliver to young people can be distilled down to "if you do all the things right that are within your power, then your dreams will come true". Consider its contrapositive.
Read more

The Scottish Curriculum: A Beginner's Guide

Image
There is no universally agreed meaning for the term "curriculum" as applied to the education of children and young people. In academic circles it is a highly contested concept, and covers everything experienced by children and young people, within or without formal education. To an average parent, I guess it means "the stuff schools are going to teach children and young people". From this perspective, Scotland has no national curriculum. Scotland has no national framework which spells out explicitly what knowledge schools should teach children and young people. We used to have one, called 5-14, but it was decided that this was too prescriptive.

Instead, the Scottish Curriculum for Excellence has a series of statements called the Experiences and Outcomes, which make vague, implicit references to the knowledge we expect young people to acquire, wrapped up in highly general statements about what we expect young people to be able to do, and what we expect them to exper…
Read more